Carmen is the tale of a free-spirited working-class woman who finds herself briefly in love with a soldier before tiring of him and choosing another lover. The soldier then murders her out of jealousy and spite. As well as the recommendations I had received, I was eager to see this piece as I had been obsessed with the 1954 film, Carmen Jones, as a teenager, singing “Dere’s a Café On De Corner” for a Musical Theatre Exam. Despite being written in the 1800s, this opera is incredibly current in 2019, where women are not treated as equals to their male counterparts. The gender pay gap in the UK is still a shameful stain on our society, and women continue to struggle to achieve the same level of professional success that men have had for generations. Carmen, a woman who refuses to be owned or controlled, dies for her beliefs, and it is saddening how much I identify with her character over 150 years on from its inception.

The modern, favela-inspired set was an interesting idea, although anyone who has seen a favela will know that they are much less clean-cut than the set for this production might suggest. Moreover, Virginie Verrez’s vocal performance was impressive, however I did not feel that her performance possessed enough sex appeal for such a larger-than-life character who causes a stir because of her sexual appetite. Carmen has little to no money, education or social standing, so her physical appeal and sexual prowess become her way to gain agency in her life.

The other prominent female personage in the piece, Micaela, is in stark contrast to Carmen. She is the woman that women are ‘supposed to be’ – meek and mild, weak and anything but wild. Although she represents an ideal of femininity that Carmen refuses to adhere to, she too is made miserable by Don José’s actions. Micaela’s survival in juxtaposition to Carmen’s demise suggests that women who express sexual desire and independent thought will come to a sticky end. The heartbroken Don José is an embodiment of the consequences of hegemonic masculinity and a male inability to accept rejection from women. When he learns that he cannot possess Carmen, he decides to destroy her, burying any evidence that might question his masculinity. Bizet’s daring orchestral score was masterfully performed by the Orchestra of the Welsh National Opera, with perfect timing and execution from both the musicians and the vocalists. This thrilling production brings Bizet’s masterpiece into the 21st century, with great performances from Verrez and Pittas, and a charming contribution from young performers too!





























